The later Empire, reeling from the "Crisis of the Third Century," stood on the precipice. This was an age defined by economic madness—a frantic scramble by the state to pay for an impossibly large army and endless public works while its currency was literally melting in its hands. The tale is of Emperor Diocletian and his disastrous attempt to impose control on chaos.
The root rot was National Debt and Fiscal Decay. For decades, emperors had desperately financed wars and bribed the legions by engaging in severe currency debasement. They reduced the intrinsic value of the silver denarius and the antoninianus to near nothing, flooding the market with coins that were barely more than copper with a silver wash.
The inevitable consequence followed: Hyperinflation. Prices skyrocketed as citizens—from soldiers to merchants—demanded more and more of the worthless coins to equal the value of the goods they were selling. In some parts of the Empire, the price of goods increased by 15,000%. The government's bills could only be paid by minting more worthless money, spiraling the state into insolvency.
The Tyranny of the Price Tag
In A.D. 301, Diocletian—a man of rigid order who could not tolerate disorder—issued one of history's most famously failed economic policies: the Edict on Maximum Prices (Edictum de Pretiis Rerum Venalium).
This was a colossal act of state-sponsored delusion. The Edict fixed the maximum price for over a thousand goods, services, and wages, from a bushel of wheat to the fee paid to a lawyer. The penalty for charging more than the official, maximum price was execution. Diocletian effectively substituted the Tyranny of the Narrative for the Law of Supply and Demand. He declared that prices were rising not because the money was worthless, but because the merchants were greedy.
The result was textbook economic collapse:
* Shortages and Hoarding: Merchants and farmers, unable to sell their goods at a profit—or often, at a price that even covered their costs—simply withdrew from the official market. They either stopped producing or sold their goods on a vast, flourishing black market.
* Market Shutdown: The official economy seized up. Goods vanished from the storefronts of Rome's major cities. In effect, the state had successfully eliminated inflation by eliminating trade itself.
* Labor Crisis: Wages were also capped, leading skilled laborers and artisans to abandon their trades, making shortages of finished goods even worse.
Diocletian's brutal edict confirmed a painful truth: a government cannot legislate value into a debased currency. It failed to stop the inflation, caused widespread famine, and was eventually and quietly ignored, proving that the free market, however imperfect, is more powerful than a tyrant’s decree.
The Parallel: Ignoring the Inevitable
The American Republic today faces its own version of a structural, runaway fiscal crisis, exhibiting the core Roman decay:
* The Debased Dollar and the Debt Pile: Where Rome debased the metal in the denarius, America debases the confidence in its currency by expanding the money supply and accepting levels of national debt that are mathematically unpayable under current policy. This constant deficit spending is our modern currency debasement—it is the financial equivalent of continually reducing the silver content of the coin to pay the legions (e.g., funding trillion-dollar budget deficits).
* The Tyranny of the Narrative (Economic Edition): Just as Diocletian blamed "greed" instead of money supply, modern political leaders (across the political spectrum) employ the Tyranny of the Narrative to misdirect blame. They demonize corporations, speculators, or foreign trade when the true cause is the fundamental, structural mismatch between what the state spends and what the state collects. Any attempt to enforce price controls (or wage controls) in a modern economy, whether on insulin, energy, or labor, is the ghostly echo of Diocletian's disastrous attempt to substitute political will for economic law.
* The Inevitable Outcome: The Roman experience teaches that when a state sacrifices fiscal prudence to sustain an imperial lifestyle and placate special interests, the end result is a collapse of the currency and the economy. The crisis will not be solved by threats of execution but by the painful restoration of monetary discipline and a severe downsizing of the imperial scope—a lesson the American political class seems determined to ignore.
No comments:
Post a Comment