The current affairs of Washington State’s McNeil Island, where a critical internal watchdog report was allegedly suppressed, leading to the removal of the center's CEO—a clear attempt to prioritize institutional secrecy over public accountability—is not merely a scandal. It is the modern iteration of an ancient, desperate tactic: the attempt to control reality by erasing the record.
The Roman Empire had a terrifying legal recourse for this act of historical obliteration: Damnatio Memoriae—the "Condemnation of Memory."
The citizens of Washington are asked to swallow a grotesque fiscal reality: the Island Factor bleeds millions, yet any report revealing the rot, or any CEO who points toward rational change, must be silenced or removed. The system defends its inefficiency with the zeal of a cult defending its high priest. The problem is not merely the $6.6 million in waste; the problem is the unwritten, political decree that the truth about that waste must vanish.
Across the centuries, the same desperate need to control the narrative drove the Roman Senate. When an Emperor became too monstrous, too incompetent, or too politically toxic—like Caligula or Nero—the Senate would sometimes decree the Damnatio Memoriae.
This was not a mere posthumous punishment; it was a total obliteration of a man’s existence from the state’s reality. Imagine the frenzy: Every statue was torn down and smashed. Every inscription bearing his name was chiseled off public buildings and monuments. His face was physically scrubbed from relief carvings and even the small, ubiquitous images on the coinage. His laws were nullified. His very name became taboo.
The purpose was profound: to create a retroactive truth that this tyrannical reign had simply never happened. The populace was meant to look at a newly blank pedestal in the Forum and accept the state’s official, convenient lie.
The connection to the McNeil Island CEO's removal and the alleged suppression of his critical report is chillingly direct. The state bureaucracy, unable and unwilling to solve a problem—the irrational cost of the island—chooses the path of the Emperor. It decides to erase the very evidence of the problem. The CEO becomes the modern Nero, not for his wickedness, but for his inconvenient truth-telling. He is condemned; his name is tarnished in the press, and the report he authored is sealed away—all to protect the institutional lie that the current, self-destructive operation is the only possible way. The political system is performing a Damnatio Memoriae on the facts.
In both eras, the effect on the people who are supposedly “asleep” is insidious. When the Senate decreed an Emperor’s erasure, the people learned a dark lesson: the reality you see with your own eyes is irrelevant; only the official, sanctioned reality matters. Today, when the taxpayer sees a scandal, only to watch the whistleblower vanish and the critical report disappear, they learn the same thing: The institutions exist to protect themselves, not the truth.
The citizens may continue to “sleep,” but their trust in the institutions that govern them has been destroyed. They have seen the reality of the island, and then they have seen the state’s furious attempt to whitewash the historical record. This constant cycle of institutional deceit is how the foundations of a Republic—built on accountability and shared truth—are slowly, deliberately, undermined, paving the way for a system where only the arbitrary will of the powerful remains.
No comments:
Post a Comment